MSNBC Home
Newsvine Home
MSN Home
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement

Did Ashley and Macy deserve to go home?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Results with 32 short comments
Total of 3,306 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

3.4%
Ashley deserved to go home
114 votes
15.5%
Macy deserved to go home
514 votes
74.4%
They both deserved to go home
2,461 votes
6.6%
Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.
217 votes
Display Comments:
Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

The felon should have been sent home.

{"commentId":9675586,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"cleboeuf"}
  • 9 votes
#1
 - Cy08
 - 10:17 pm EDT on Wed Sep 23, 2009
They both deserved to go home

Yes. and the next will be Kathy Ireland, Michael Irvin and Delay.

{"commentId":9676544,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"icreate"}
    #2
     - Giselle-360273
     - 11:25 pm EDT on Wed Sep 23, 2009
    Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

    Tom DeLay shaking his butt was gross. That alone should have sent him home.

    {"commentId":9676592,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"ms-diva2000"}
    • 6 votes
    #3
     - LakersGirl
     - 11:28 pm EDT on Wed Sep 23, 2009
    Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

    The obvious choice was "delay-ed" - really nauseating performance that gave me the creeps. LOSER!!!

    {"commentId":9676624,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"historic-works"}
    • 6 votes
    #4
     - Roz-580479
     - 11:30 pm EDT on Wed Sep 23, 2009
    They both deserved to go home

    macy was a freak and ashley wasn't even as good as his dad

    {"commentId":9676775,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"hunsister"}
      #5
       - hunsister
       - 11:43 pm EDT on Wed Sep 23, 2009
      Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

      I am so tired of the Osmonds. Please send him home.

      {"commentId":9676930,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"jlocks"}
      • 2 votes
      #6
       - Angry Left-532262
       - 11:57 pm EDT on Wed Sep 23, 2009
      They both deserved to go home

      If only Macy were as pretty as Ashley, and Ashley were as manly as Macy! But I thought Macy had great Cloris Leachman potential!

      {"commentId":9676956,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"joyolson26"}
        #7
         - Joy O
         - 11:59 pm EDT on Wed Sep 23, 2009
        They both deserved to go home

        never watch the show.

        {"commentId":9677118,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"rwoods-1"}
          #8
           - mscarter
           - 12:13 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
          Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

          Get rid of Tom Delay!

          {"commentId":9677223,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"nbowers"}
          • 4 votes
          #9
           - NaninIowa
           - 12:20 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
          They both deserved to go home

          They were so bad, I also want back the ten minutes I wasted watching them.

          {"commentId":9677245,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"delphia2000"}
          • 1 vote
          #10
           - kenaiqueen
           - 12:22 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
          They both deserved to go home

          Good choices - he was stiff and she - disinterested. Kelly, Mya, Donnie and the guy from Top Chef (?) were all great - Team DJ, too!

          {"commentId":9677372,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"rpcvbg"}
            #11
             - Heather in Columbus, OH
             - 12:35 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
            Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

            tom delay needs to be sent packing - arrogant, creepy and a total buffoon on the dance floor

            {"commentId":9677547,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"palane3"}
            • 6 votes
            #12
             - padrepete
             - 12:52 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
            Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

            Tom Delay, obscene, send him home!

            {"commentId":9677664,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"elenalb"}
            • 5 votes
            #13
             - hilda-458571
             - 1:08 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
            Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

            Tom Delay deserved to go home. His performance was at best cheesy, but often crossed the line to sleesy.

            {"commentId":9677898,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"Sylvia-1324369"}
            • 5 votes
            #14
             - Sylvia-1325369
             - 1:43 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
            They both deserved to go home

            Macy didn't put the time in.

            {"commentId":9677927,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"ctcoleman"}
              #15
               - Chris in Colorado
               - 1:49 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
              Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

              Is Tom Delay going to use his $ and power to buy the mirrored ball? He is sooo sleazy!

              {"commentId":9677960,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"crackersnacker"}
              • 4 votes
              #16
               - crackersnacker
               - 1:55 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
              Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

              Tom DeLay. Yuck.

              {"commentId":9678569,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"goblue1321"}
              • 3 votes
              #17
               - GoBlue-1316956
               - 5:42 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
              They both deserved to go home

              Oh joyous day Macy Gray is gone. Now I can watch dancing with both eyes open! As to Ashley, so what!

              {"commentId":9679322,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"urlonz"}
                #18
                 - Url
                 - 8:17 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
                They both deserved to go home

                It is going to be an interesting season.

                {"commentId":9679888,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"mvic"}
                  #19
                   - zbugs
                   - 9:03 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
                  They both deserved to go home

                  Ashley who? and if MG didn't want to be there, why was she recruited in the first place?

                  {"commentId":9680077,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"scdead"}
                    #20
                     - scdead
                     - 9:16 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
                    Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

                    I think Tom Delay should've been sent home first. I expected Macy to go home, but wished she could stick around for another week.

                    {"commentId":9681099,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"sabrina-berry"}
                    • 2 votes
                    #21
                     - Sabrina-681982
                     - 10:09 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
                    They both deserved to go home

                    They were the worst.

                    {"commentId":9681418,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"dgdavis60"}
                      #22
                       - DIANA-496313
                       - 10:24 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
                      They both deserved to go home

                      Sadly, Ashley can't dance and it seemed as if Macy didn't want to be there.

                      {"commentId":9681675,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"peter-fields"}
                        #23
                         - Peter Fields
                         - 10:35 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
                        They both deserved to go home

                        We all got it right this time!

                        {"commentId":9682502,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"dan-johnson"}
                        • 1 vote
                        #24
                         - D2-686590
                         - 11:09 am EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009
                        Someone else deserved to go home, and I will list that person in the comments below.

                        Tom Delay should have went home. Seeing him shake his big fat azz on camera was nasty. I thought i was watching Rated X movie

                        {"commentId":9685953,"threadId":"684398","contentId":"3307249","authorDomain":"roger-thacker"}
                        • 2 votes
                        #25
                         - Roger Thacker
                         - 1:19 pm EDT on Thu Sep 24, 2009