MSNBC Home
Newsvine Home
MSN Home
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement

Would 'American Idol' succeed without Simon Cowell?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Results with 6 short comments
Total of 766 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

7.7%
Yes, it's about the singers, not the judges
59 votes
81.6%
No, he holds the whole show together
625 votes
10.7%
Maybe, if they found a great replacement
82 votes
Display Comments:
No, he holds the whole show together

The show is getting tired anyway. Simon can go and kill the show or stay and it will die of old age. I think it is fixed anyway.

{"commentId":9906485,"threadId":"694442","contentId":"3354704","authorDomain":"lottie-dah113"}
    #1
     - Lottie-dah
     - 3:30 pm EDT on Tue Oct 6, 2009
    No, he holds the whole show together

    Simon IS American Idol...without him, they might as well fall on their sword....

    {"commentId":9916226,"threadId":"694442","contentId":"3354704","authorDomain":"plldgrn"}
      #2
       - plldgrn
       - 7:08 am EDT on Wed Oct 7, 2009
      Maybe, if they found a great replacement

      This show sucks anyway so who cares if he is a judge or not. It is time to put the public of its misery and cancel the show. Move on people

      {"commentId":9917947,"threadId":"694442","contentId":"3354704","authorDomain":"djwatts1"}
        #3
         - deedee-673572
         - 9:38 am EDT on Wed Oct 7, 2009
        No, he holds the whole show together

        frankly I want Cowell to go back to England and live happily forever with his money. The guy is a cad. Who cares about AI-show sux.

        {"commentId":9935026,"threadId":"694442","contentId":"3354704","authorDomain":"cadrecreative1"}
          #4
           - cadre57
           - 11:06 pm EDT on Wed Oct 7, 2009
          No, he holds the whole show together

          Simon is consistently the most entertaining thing about AI.

          {"commentId":9943535,"threadId":"694442","contentId":"3354704","authorDomain":"mchris1947"}
            #5
             - Mchris1947
             - 12:35 pm EDT on Thu Oct 8, 2009
            No, he holds the whole show together

            Everyone loves a curmudgeon, especially one with a well hidden soft spot.

            {"commentId":10026905,"threadId":"694442","contentId":"3354704","authorDomain":"walliePA"}
              #6
               - Wallie-PA
               - 1:50 pm EDT on Mon Oct 12, 2009