MSNBC Home
Newsvine Home
MSN Home
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement
More tagged ,

Is 'Glee' overrated?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Results with 21 short comments
Total of 2,752 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

64.4%
No, it's awesome
1,772 votes
16.1%
Yes, it's just not that great
442 votes
19.5%
A little, but give it a full season before judging
538 votes
Display Comments:
No, it's awesome

It does need to work on the scripts tho or it could end up a one season wonder...i love it tho!

{"commentId":10075728,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"dinanak"}
  • 1 vote
#1
 - Dinana
 - 11:22 am EDT on Wed Oct 14, 2009
Yes, it's just not that great

In their quest to be different, they ended up the same.

{"commentId":10078981,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"peter-fields"}
  • 1 vote
#2
 - Peter Fields
 - 1:32 pm EDT on Wed Oct 14, 2009
A little, but give it a full season before judging

I love it but it needs work or it won't last

{"commentId":10079280,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"martyne"}
  • 1 vote
#3
 - martyne
 - 1:43 pm EDT on Wed Oct 14, 2009
A little, but give it a full season before judging

While the author of this article may be on point in some of the criticism. The first season is done. Can't change things till season 2.

{"commentId":10080308,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"matthewd74"}
    #4
     - md-381569
     - 2:24 pm EDT on Wed Oct 14, 2009
    No, it's awesome

    Worst article ever!

    {"commentId":10080980,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"franklintherocker"}
    • 4 votes
    #5
     - jarmo-547986
     - 2:56 pm EDT on Wed Oct 14, 2009
    No, it's awesome

    The characters are one note because so many people desperately try to be a one note person. The humor is biting and the music is great !

    {"commentId":10082145,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"egoliad206"}
    • 3 votes
    #6
     - monalouise
     - 3:45 pm EDT on Wed Oct 14, 2009
    Yes, it's just not that great

    I dislike it.

    {"commentId":10082218,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"carolync-1"}
      #7
       - carolyn-452703
       - 3:48 pm EDT on Wed Oct 14, 2009
      No, it's awesome

      The freshest, unique, funny and different show on television. Flashbacks for me!

      {"commentId":10083287,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"kevind"}
      • 3 votes
      #8
       - kevind
       - 4:38 pm EDT on Wed Oct 14, 2009
      No, it's awesome

      Glee is a refreshingly original look at the unoriginal. Who wasn't at least one of those stereotypes? Sad, true and great fun!! Go Glee!

      {"commentId":10090283,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"fionaferguson"}
      • 2 votes
      #9
       - MaineGirl4Obama
       - 11:28 pm EDT on Wed Oct 14, 2009
      No, it's awesome

      LOVE IT!

      {"commentId":10091951,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"ducky0397"}
      • 2 votes
      #10
       - ducky0397
       - 3:12 am EDT on Thu Oct 15, 2009
      Yes, it's just not that great

      This gynophobic show is a collection of domineering neurotic women and men who are desperately afraid of them. Can they lipsynch depth??

      {"commentId":10092119,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"kingkia"}
      • 1 vote
      #11
       - kingkia
       - 4:07 am EDT on Thu Oct 15, 2009
      No, it's awesome

      Glee is one of the few things I look forward to each week.The singing is always uplifting.Get rid of the pregnancy crap and it will be grea

      {"commentId":10092344,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"Joanne-1413023"}
      • 2 votes
      #12
       - Joanne-1413023
       - 5:44 am EDT on Thu Oct 15, 2009
      No, it's awesome

      NBC should take a lesson for Glee! Its a free clinic every Wednesday night @ 9p!!!

      {"commentId":10092631,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"nomosti"}
      • 1 vote
      #13
       - NoMoSTi
       - 7:10 am EDT on Thu Oct 15, 2009
      No, it's awesome

      Not overrated, but the article hit the nail on the head. Characters need more development.

      {"commentId":10093564,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"shannonwilkerson"}
        #14
         - Mr. Shannon Wilkerson
         - 8:59 am EDT on Thu Oct 15, 2009
        No, it's awesome

        Yes, the characters need to grow out of their stereotypes but overall this is the best show I've seen in years and years.

        {"commentId":10094124,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"cordeliapotter"}
          #15
           - CordeliaPotter
           - 9:36 am EDT on Thu Oct 15, 2009
          Yes, it's just not that great

          people really want to love it.

          {"commentId":10094531,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"rjohnson-8"}
            #16
             - Rodney J
             - 9:57 am EDT on Thu Oct 15, 2009
            A little, but give it a full season before judging

            Yeah, it's spinning it's wheels. Too many creepy characters, too many stupid characters. The not pregnant wife scares the hell out of me.

            {"commentId":10094619,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"david-stever"}
              #17
               - stever-man
               - 10:01 am EDT on Thu Oct 15, 2009
              No, it's awesome

              I suppose it would be possible for it to be overrated if it weren't for the fact that most of other tv shows are trash and reality shows!

              {"commentId":10096649,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"michael311"}
                #18
                 - Michael Martinez-430183
                 - 11:34 am EDT on Thu Oct 15, 2009
                Yes, it's just not that great

                It 's no FAME, sadly ..talent there, but all wasted on a ho hum goofy satire

                {"commentId":10122769,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"kittyspurrr2"}
                  #19
                   - kittyspurrr 2
                   - 1:47 pm EDT on Fri Oct 16, 2009
                  No, it's awesome

                  Don't usually watch teenybopper shows. When I saw the guy coming out to his dad thought it was an independent movie. Great acting.

                  {"commentId":10123386,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"carlos-v-1171316"}
                  • 1 vote
                  #20
                   - Carlos V-1171316
                   - 2:15 pm EDT on Fri Oct 16, 2009
                  A little, but give it a full season before judging

                  Glee made it to my DVR list but I have higher hopes for the writing/character development after hearing the Ryan Murphy interview on NPR.

                  {"commentId":10140844,"threadId":"701038","contentId":"3378795","authorDomain":"life-is-too-short"}
                    #21
                     - Life_Is_Too_Short
                     - 5:54 pm EDT on Sat Oct 17, 2009