MSNBC Home
Newsvine Home
MSN Home
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement

Are the 'Project Runway' judges getting too harsh?

Michael Kors’ and Nina Garcia’s prolonged absences seem to be hurting "Project Runway" this season. There seems to be an utter lack of continuity on the panel, and some fans say judging has been unnecessarily harsh of late.

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Results with 8 short comments
Total of 558 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

55.9%
Yes, it ruins the show.
312 votes
30.1%
Maybe, sometimes contestants deserve it.
168 votes
14%
No, the contestants need tougher skin.
78 votes
Display Comments:
Yes, it ruins the show.

The elimination of Gordana was diabolical. She answered the challenge of the week perfectly. She should have been in the top 2.

{"commentId":10647654,"threadId":"723091","contentId":"3495277","authorDomain":"cymraeg19"}
    #1
     - Lyn-405767
     - 6:39 pm EST on Thu Nov 12, 2009
    Yes, it ruins the show.

    Oh heck yeah! Epperson, Ra'mon & Shirin never should've been eliminated before Christopher, Logan or Nicholas.

    {"commentId":10648508,"threadId":"723091","contentId":"3495277","authorDomain":"singpretty"}
    • 1 vote
    #2
     - singpretty
     - 7:29 pm EST on Thu Nov 12, 2009
    Maybe, sometimes contestants deserve it.

    This season's contestants have been sooo boring and uninspiring - I long for the days of Christina, Rame, Jullien, and Chris March! BORING

    {"commentId":10649854,"threadId":"723091","contentId":"3495277","authorDomain":"khinga"}
      #3
       - khinga
       - 8:49 pm EST on Thu Nov 12, 2009
      Yes, it ruins the show.

      We saw some of the better designers sent home.

      {"commentId":10664726,"threadId":"723091","contentId":"3495277","authorDomain":"dsandjl1"}
        #4
         - dsandjl1
         - 2:56 pm EST on Fri Nov 13, 2009
        Yes, it ruins the show.

        I was disappointed with the final three selection - I'm curious what would have happened if Kors and Nina were there more regularly.

        {"commentId":10703023,"threadId":"723091","contentId":"3495277","authorDomain":"historia18"}
          #5
           - historia18
           - 1:20 pm EST on Mon Nov 16, 2009
          Yes, it ruins the show.

          This season has been BORING...snooze...the contestant's had no FLAIR and their designs were always safe

          {"commentId":10705667,"threadId":"723091","contentId":"3495277","authorDomain":"wondersharon1"}
            #6
             - winky-1050641
             - 3:13 pm EST on Mon Nov 16, 2009
            Maybe, sometimes contestants deserve it.

            Overall, the lack of Michael and Nina degraded the show-even more than a reality show can be degraded....

            {"commentId":10725444,"threadId":"723091","contentId":"3495277","authorDomain":"susan66203"}
            • 1 vote
            #7
             - Suz in KS
             - 12:22 pm EST on Tue Nov 17, 2009
            Maybe, sometimes contestants deserve it.

            Inconsistent is the best description. Kors and Garcia must be there more often or they need to be replaced.

            {"commentId":10725884,"threadId":"723091","contentId":"3495277","authorDomain":"alicarn11"}
            • 1 vote
            #8
             - alice-280680
             - 12:35 pm EST on Tue Nov 17, 2009